Sean Astin Unravels All the Secrets About His Biological Father

If you’re asked the word for someone who finds positives and makes something good out of a bad situation, you’ll most likely say an optimist. But we’ve got another word (or words) – Sean Astin. Imagine being told your entire life that your father could be anybody.

Source: Getty Images

Not many people can keep their cool after that. But Sean Astin did. If you didn’t already adore him for his loveable portrayal of Samwise Gamgee in Lord of the Rings or when he played Rudy in Rudy, his real-life strength for positivity will warm your heart.

Let’s Go Back to the Beginning

Sean Astin was originally born Sean Patrick Duke on February 25, 1971 – with his mother’s surname because his father’s identity was unknown at the time. Don’t worry, we’ll explain when it changed and why. Stay tuned! So, why didn’t his mother know his father?

Source: Tumblr

Well, Sean’s mother, Patty, was between relationships for just a matter of days when she found out she was with child. This made it difficult to be sure who the real father was. And she wasn’t the only one interested in knowing this information.

The Young Patty Duke

While being pregnant is great, it can significantly alter your life, especially when you’re young. Patty Duke was only 23 when she got pregnant, but she already had a viable acting career behind her. She made her stage debut at the age of 13, following in her brother’s footsteps.

Source: United Artists

She had made a name for herself as one of the youngest actresses to ever win an Academy Award for her portrayal of Helen Keller in The Miracle Worker. However, as one of America’s most popular young stars, Patty was constantly scrutinized by the public.

Not the Most Auspicious Start to Her Career

When you ask most celebrities today, you’ll learn that many of them had a pretty rough start. Patty had been pushed into child acting by insensitive managers and a mother who couldn’t care for her. These managers were a married couple who helped young stars develop into disciplined adult actors.

Photo by Bettmann/Getty Images

They had high hopes for Patty’s older brother at first, but as Patty grew older, they saw more prospects in her and quickly shifted all of their attention to her. Their strategy was to basically adopt her, and as such, they had complete control over her time and life.

The Birth of a Superstar

And they did all they could to control everything. First, as she discusses in her autobiography, “Call Me Anna,” they changed her name. They removed her accent. Next, they decided not only to look for acting opportunities for her but also to decide which ones she would accept or reject.

Photo by Henry Gris/FPG/Getty Images

It didn’t matter whether she was interested in the project. Patty began to speak up for herself against the traumatic expectations of young stardom at a pretty late age for normal teenage rebellion. She was desperate to have a say in her life.

A Desperate Attempt to Escape

Although most teenage rebellions started relatively earlier than Patty Duke’s, she was still trying her best to take control of her life and career. Her managers, on the other hand, were equally determined to keep her under lock and key. They found ways to intervene.

Source: Tumblr

And Patty would find ways to avoid them. It didn’t take long for her to feel trapped in this life that had been predetermined for her, and she felt compelled to escape. That’s when the media began to take notice of some of her more public decisions.

Seeking Refuge in Marriage

Marriage seems to be a haven for many people…until it isn’t anymore. Her big opportunity to escape seemed to have come while on the set of The Patty Duke Show, a sitcom based on her personality and rise to stardom which was named after her.

Photo by Earl Leaf/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

She and director Harry Falk became close and started dating, which led him to notice that her managers excessively controlled her. He proposed to her, and by accepting him, she was finally free of her bosses. Unfortunately, like most celebrity marriages, their marriage only lasted a few years.

The Marriage Made Her Independent

While divorce or separation is unfortunate in most cases, sometimes, it is what’s best for both parties. Or one of them. Even though her marriage to Harry Falk ended, it was the precursor for her eventual freedom from her child star bondage and reliance on her guardians.

Source: YouTube

When her marriage failed, Patty took some time to herself, concentrating on her career. However, a few years later, she was involved in a heavily criticized affair with another star child, Desi Arnaz Jr. This fling ended almost as quickly as it began, which was unsurprising to some.

The In-Laws-to-be Didn’t Fancy Her

Many people consider it important for the spouse’s parents to approve. Arnaz’s parents, actors Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz, publicly condemned the affair because their son was six years younger than Patty. But Patty was still young and unprepared to deal with having so much of her life documented.

Source: Imgur

However, things took an unexpected turn when a visitor she hosted named Michael Tell offered to make a show of marrying her to divert attention away from Arnaz, and that’s how Patty ended up with husband #2 – for a total of 13 days.

The Unconventional Type of Love

Patty and Michael were never close during their time together. Well, you wouldn’t expect much from a sham marriage that was planned so quickly under those circumstances. This was why she didn’t consider her second marriage to be significant – not realizing it would have an impact on her future.

Photo by Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection/Getty Images

She soon began a new relationship with another actor, John Astin. John was still married but separated, which hampered their relationship’s potential for a time. That’s when Patty discovered she was expecting Sean. So, you see where Sean’s fatherhood dilemma originated from, right?

She Made a Decision Immediately

There’s something called “motherly instinct.” Only mothers can do justice to that feeling, so we won’t even try. But you’ll understand it from Patty’s decision. Patty knew right away that she wanted to give her unborn child a different life than what she had growing up.

Photo by Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection/Getty Images

However, that was difficult considering she didn’t know who the father was. No matter how much she or John loved each other, she felt that bringing a baby into their relationship could be more than he had anticipated; he signed up to be a boyfriend, not a father.

Sean Gets a Father

Everyone who’s had a child knows what a huge responsibility it is. And even bigger for John considering he already had three from a previous marriage. Neither John nor Patty knew if she was carrying his child, but fortunately for Patty, he was prepared to care for her child.

Source: Imgur

In exchange, Patty offered to care for John’s three children from his previous marriage. After his divorce was finalized, the two married in 1972, with a 1-year-old Sean present. Sean exclaimed loudly, “Daddy!” and their future together was sealed – at least their immediate future.

Sean Gets a New Dad

Patty’s relationship with John, on the other hand, did not last as long as Sean’s. John and Patty’s marriage started having troubles in 1984, and they divorced in 1985. This turn of events gave Patty the feeling that it was finally time to tell Sean the truth…

Photo by FPG, Getty Images / Source: YouTube

…John might not have been his father. For the first time, he learned that a total stranger from his mother’s past – Desi Arnaz Jr. – could be his father. This must have been a bombshell for Sean since John was who he grew up calling Dad.

Still His Dad Forever

This discovery was a huge turning point in Sean’s life. Sean adored the man he had come to know as his father, even to this day. It wasn’t difficult for him to decide that even if they didn’t share blood, John would remain an important person in his life.

Photo by Ron Galella, Ltd, Ron Galella Collection, Getty Images / Matt Winkelmeyer, Getty Images

But that did not solve his inner conflict about what to do with the knowledge his mother had just given him. After all, he still wanted to be sure who he shared blood with. He wondered if he could ever adjust to having a different father.

Well, Not Everyone Has Two Dads!

Just like it is his personality, Sean decided to look on the bright side in this new discovery! Despite his positive relationship with his large family, he chose to accept his mother’s words and contact the man he now presumed to be his biological father.

Source: Reddit

Once he and Arnaz met, they took to each other immediately, and he didn’t want to end their connection with a simple meeting. He chose to pursue a genuine bond with Arnaz, which blossomed and continues to this day. He was only 14 years old at the time.

Becoming an Adult Early on

He was just 14, but Sean already faced real-life issues that aren’t common to the average teenager. Sean entered adulthood with a lot on his plate: a single mother, two fathers, and any inner turmoil that resulted from discovering that something he’d believed his entire life was false.

Source: Twitter

But he did so with a lot of willpower and positive vibes – determined to see the positive side. He was strong not only for himself but also for his mother – whose childhood issues influenced her adulthood – and for his fatherly figures, who felt some responsibility for his position.

He Remained Focused on His Dreams

It’s easy to lose sight of your goals and lose yourself when you’re faced with big problems as a teenager. But thankfully, Sean remained focused on his dreams. He did not let the confusion about his biological father deter him from pursuing a successful acting career.

Source: Imgur

In 1985, the same year he received this revelation and had his reality shattered, he was cast as Mikey Walsh in The Goonies, playing the endearing type that he seemed to be in real life and that he would go on to play in several other feature films.

The Daddy Issues Didn’t Go Away

While the young Sean was trying his best to move on with his dreams, comfortable with having two dads, something strange happened. In the midst of Sean’s burgeoning acting career, he was approached by a stranger with even more unexpected and unwelcome news about his father.

Source: Tumblr

The man turned out to be a relative of Sean’s mother’s second husband, Michael Tell, who claimed to be Sean’s biological father. Given the brief and unromantic nature of this marriage, it seemed unthinkable. But it opened a door that Sean had never been able to close before.

The Questions Kept Piling up

This new person who came into the fray put more into disarray. Sean’s brief encounter with Michael Tell’s relative revealed much more in the end. It forced Sean to face the fact that he still didn’t know the truth about his father.

Photo by Michael Ochs Archive, Getty Images / Paul Archuleta, FilmMagic, Getty Images

At this stage, his father’s identity had already been called into question and settled several times, with Sean having to psychologically adjust to the news each time. It had to be emotionally draining. He didn’t feel prepared to take in any more news without a little more certainty this time.

Time to Solve the Mystery Once and for All

The mystery could only go on for so long before there came a point where it had to be solved. Sean’s life was going well at this point, and he was thankful for it. He was raised by a caring father. He grew up in a large and close-knit family.

Photo by Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/Getty Images

He was already happily married to his wife for nearly 10 years. Following in his mother’s footsteps, he was enjoying a successful acting career. So, despite his obvious frustration with the complicated situation, he was mostly just curious – and he decided to unravel the mystery once and for all.

Taking One Last Step

You’ve probably been thinking, “why not just get a DNA test?” Well, Sean was born in 1971 and paternal DNA testing only became a thing in the early ’90s. He resolved that a paternal DNA test was the only way to obtain the information and answers he needed.

Source: Imgur / Photo by Jim Spellman, WireImage, Getty Images

He was prepared to shut the door that had previously remained open to others, allowing them to repeatedly destabilize his life. But, to be certain, he needed to contact the last entrant who hadn’t been a part of his life thus far. So he tracked down Michael Tell.

The Last Father Standing

The testing was carried out after Michael and the other two men he suspected of being his father agreed, and the results revealed that Michael Tell was, in fact, his biological father. Everyone thought it was the least likely answer because Michael and Patty only knew each other briefly.

Source: Reddit / Photo by Jason Kempin, Getty Images

However, the truth appears to be quite clear from this picture. When he found out this information, Sean contacted Michael again to ask for one more favor – and that was to get to know each other. It was the least he could do to make up for all those years.

Patty Didn’t Believe the Test Results

Sean and Michael began to form a relationship just like he had relationships with the other father figures in his life. It was important to make up for the lost time when Michael didn’t know he had fathered a son. Whether it was brought together by love, science…

Source: Diane Krauss/CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

…or both, their relationship clearly demonstrates that it’s impossible not to like Sean Astin. His mother, on the other hand, had a more difficult time accepting the test results. When asked about it, she stated, “I can support his truth as long as my truth, if not supported, is respected.”

Patty’s Teenage Issues Were the Source

Patty Duke didn’t grow up like a normal child with no real-life problems. She faced issues that ultimately shaped her entire life, and Sean’s, too. Patty, as well as some of her relationships around the time of Sean’s birth, were scrutinized by the public from an early age.

Photo by Bettmann/Getty Images

From the outside, she appeared to be hopping from one relationship to the next far too quickly. America cared about its sweetheart – but didn’t know where Patty had come from or who or what had repetitively pushed her in difficult directions.

The Battles We Didn’t Know Patty Fought

It’s easy to see and judge celebrities from the outside without knowing what they’re going through. Despite the problems that made Patty’s adolescence difficult, Hollywood was even better at hiding mental illnesses back then than it is now. In fact, she experienced some episodes during filming.

Source: Pinterest

The cast and crew witnessed the episodes as they happened, but the news was kept very quiet. So it wasn’t until Patty was in her 50s that the world learned for the first time that she had suffered from mental illness for the majority of her life.

Patty Began Speaking up

It’s important to talk about the struggles we go through. And although it was later on in her life, Patty began speaking up. She later decided to go public with her bipolar disorder. She then wanted to take the knowledge further by speaking up for others.

Photo by Jesse Grant/WireImage/Getty Images

So she decided to become a mental health advocate, spending the rest of her life proposing more funding and research. But holding on to the solace you can find in the world is part of surviving with mental illnesses, and for Patty, it was her belief about Sean’s father.

Sean Is an Understanding Person…and Son

Sean’s loveable personality isn’t just in the movies; he’s exactly the same way in real life and his relationship with people in his life. Sean was hurt by Patty’s dismissal, but it did not affect on his relationship with her or any of his fatherly figures.

Photo by David S. Holloway/Getty Images

Though her objection may appear strange, Patty’s emotional turmoil played a significant role in her life. Unlike Sean, his mother was not willing to open her heart to various possibilities, especially in such a delicate situation. Can you really blame her? Sean didn’t.

Not Your Regular Family

When you consider the difficult hand Sean Astin was dealt as a child, his open heart is impressive. He has accepted not one, but three fatherly figures into his life, even though many of them entered without warning and two were not his biological father.

Photo by Brenda Chase/Getty Images

He maintained healthy relationships with all of them, despite uncertain and sometimes unfavorable circumstances, demonstrating how much he valued each of them as individuals. This also tells you a lot about who he is as a person and how easy it is to have a connection with him.

A Great Character Both Personally and Professionally

It’s safe to say that the strength that Sean showed in his personal life as he dealt with strange twists, and repeated emotional damage that could have hurt more than it did, is the same strength that continually surfaced in his acting career.

Source: YouTube

It’s not far-fetched to say difficulties like this from an early age can damage others. Sean’s career never ceased to fulfill him because he found a way to channel the strength he gained from his extraordinary circumstances and the gratification of many relationships.

Playing Samwise Gamgee in the Lord of the Rings

Many people got to know Sean Astin from one popular character. Sean’s career took off when he was cast as the eternally optimistic Samwise Gamgee in the popular adventure series, Lord of the Rings. Samwise joins his friend on a tough quest out of nothing more than a caring heart.

Source: New Line Cinema

This was despite a harrowing journey through Middle Earth filled with a million frightening threats. Those Samwise eyes that we saw bubble up with compassion and stop us in our tracks, it turns out, were also a feature of Sean’s in real life. What a man!

A Man With a Heart of Gold, On and Off Screen

Finally, Sean was given the kind of extended family that few people believe is even possible nowadays. And it undoubtedly couldn’t do without his good nature. But, he has made the impossible possible thanks to his uncanny efforts to see the good in any situation.

Photo by Jesse Grant/WireImage/Getty Images

And as it appears, it is so much a part of him that even his movie roles often embody it. He even has a tattoo on his ankle that reads “nine” – his involvement in Lord of the Rings. And now has the answers he has sought for so long.

Playing Rudy in Rudy

Sean Astin won hearts all over the world again in 1993 with his moving portrayal of Daniel “Rudy” Ruettiger in the movie Rudy. In this role, he portrays an ambitious young football player with no clear path to success. But he refuses to give up.

Photo by Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images / Source: Reddit

He overcomes a slew of challenges to achieve the success he’s always desired. There is no perfect ending, but the battles Rudy fights and wins leave him feeling victorious – much like Sean’s victories in real life. You can’t help but agree that they couldn’t have chosen a better actor.

Could There Be More Stranger Things?

Sean, the ever-sacrificial support system, was most recently seen on Stranger Things as the humble hero Bob Newby. Here, he volunteers to be a father figure to his girlfriend’s sons – just in time for the entire family to become stuck together in a life-or-death predicament.

Source: Twitter

He ends up getting everyone out and saves the day, but unfortunately, he doesn’t make it out alive. We wonder if the fatherly figure he plays here is inspired by any aspects of Sean’s real life. Hold on tight: things are about to get more complicated.